TL;DR: Why âThis or Thatâ Video Challenges Are Transforming Restaurant SEO
âThis or Thatâ Video Challenges are revolutionizing restaurant SEO by boosting engagement, increasing local search rankings, and driving foot traffic. Pitting two menu items against each other in short-form videos on platforms like TikTok and Instagram Reels creates interactive and shareable content that not only attracts diners but aligns perfectly with Googleâs ranking priorities.
âą Drives Engagement: Video challenges enhance emotional connection, leading to higher click-through rates (45% more than static images) and improving visibility across platforms and Google Business Profiles.
âą Boosts Local SEO: These challenges target diners actively searching for nearby restaurants, optimizing key metrics like watch duration, CTR, and authentic user response for better rankings.
âą Increases Visits: 76% of local searches with purchase intent result in visits within 24 hours, and âThis or Thatâ campaigns capitalize on this behavior to convert digital votes into real-world visits.
Take advantage of this strategy to steal the spotlight from competitors, start creating buzz for your restaurant today! For personalized guidance, check out our Restaurant SEO services.
Why âThis or Thatâ Video Challenges Are Reshaping Restaurant SEO (and Why You Canât Afford to Ignore Them)
Imagine being able to create buzz about your restaurant in seconds, filling seats within hours, and boosting your local search rankings, all with short-form video content. Sound unrealistic? Itâs not. The âThis or Thatâ video challenge is exactly how restaurants are dominating local SEO in 2026, and if youâre not part of the game, youâre losing customers to savvy competitors who are turning likes, shares, and votes into foot traffic.
The strategy is simple yet powerful: pit two menu items against each other in short videos on TikTok, Instagram Reels, or YouTube Shorts. Invite your audience to vote on their favorite, and use the winning item as a promotional hook. Itâs cheap, highly engaging, and aligned with how diners now decide where to eat. But the real magic happens behind the scenes: these videos arenât just great for engagement, theyâre ticking every box local-search algorithms look for in 2026.
Hereâs the kicker: 76% of local searches with purchase intent result in visits within a day, according to ChowNowâs TikTok playbook. And by integrating video into your strategy, restaurants see average click-through rates improve by 45% compared to static images, proof that this isnât about jumping on a trendy bandwagon. Short-form video is now the fastest-growing SEO channel for restaurants.
How does all this work? Letâs break it down.
Whatâs Behind the âThis or Thatâ Challenge?
Letâs start with the mechanics. A âThis or Thatâ video pits two items, say, your signature wood-fired pizza versus your handcrafted pasta, in an engaging, head-to-head comparison. You let viewers swipe, vote, or comment on their preference. Once a winner emerges, you drive action by promoting and offering the dish with targeted time-sensitive calls to action like: “Order the winner today!”
This doesn’t just create engagement, it satisfies critical ranking signals for local SEO. Search engines now prioritize authentic video content that directly matches user search intent, and algorithms favor restaurants that produce engaging visuals over competitors relying on static images or outdated tactics.
Hereâs why it works so well for SEO:
Authentic Content Alignment
Video content earns 12% longer average watch time compared to traditional media, making it particularly valuable for satisfying Googleâs E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) rating system. Authentic behind-the-scenes clips of your chef prepping contest dishes or customers reacting make your restaurant seem approachable and trustworthy, boosting visitor confidence and action.
Local Focus and Purchase Intent
Most diners arenât passively browsing; theyâre actively deciding where to eat. 76% of local searches with purchase intent result in a visit within 24 hours. By promoting âThis or Thatâ videos to people already searching for restaurants nearby, youâre targeting potential diners at the ideal decision-making moment.
Emotional Connection
Pairing competitive video content with emotional storytelling builds engagement. In 2026, restaurants leveraging short-form storytelling are outpacing rivals. The âThis or Thatâ challenge taps directly into curiosity (âWhich dish is better?â), personalization (âYou decide!â), and urgency (âLimited-time offer!â). Customers connect emotionally and follow through, leading to real-life visits.
How âThis or Thatâ Boosts Local SEO Rankings
You might be thinking, âSure, itâs fun for social media followers, but how does this impact my Google rankings?â Excellent question, and hereâs the answer. The challenge format aligns perfectly with Googleâs local-search priorities, which heavily weigh engagement metrics like click-through rates (CTR), watch duration, and authentic user responses.
Higher Click-Through Rates
CTR is one of the most important ranking factors for local restaurants. According to industry insights, restaurant listings featuring videos see conversion rates 45% higher than those relying on static images. By embedding âThis or Thatâ clips onto your Google Business Profile (GBP) or social platforms, youâre turning viewers into actual table bookings.
Watch Time Fuels E-E-A-T
Longer interactions signal quality content to search algorithms. With average watch times surpassing 12 seconds for âThis or Thatâ clips, youâre scoring higher E-E-A-T evaluations from Google, which wants to feature businesses delivering authentic experiences backed by relevant expertise.
Local Citations in AI-Driven Search
Itâs not just traditional SEO that benefits. AI tools like ChatGPT now aggregate data differently. Local restaurants producing concise, well-labeled videos have a better chance of appearing in AI-generated citations, making your restaurant easier to find whether diners rely on Google or chatbot suggestions for nearby options.
Crafting the Perfect Challenge Video
Not all âThis or Thatâ videos deliver the same results. To make yours stand out and generate maximum SEO impact, youâll need technical precision and creative execution.
Step 1: Define Your Contest Items
Choose dishes or drinks that highlight your restaurantâs unique strengths. Think signature entrees, seasonal specials, or items with high popularity among customers. Pair contrasting options, such as âspicy wings versus classic BBQâ or âvegan burger versus beef sliders.â Clear themes encourage engagement.
Step 2: Optimize Video Length
Gone are the days of long commercials. In 2026, the sweet spot for engagement is 15â30 seconds. Keep clips short enough to sustain attention but long enough to include enticing visuals and narration.
Step 3: Leverage Audience Poll Features
Use native features for voting. TikTok lets viewers tag favorites in comments, while Instagram and YouTube offer interactive polling tools. Make participation effortless.
Step 4: Optimize Captions and Tags with Local Intent
Just like your website title tags, video captions are prime SEO real estate. For example:
- Caption: âBattle of the Bar: Margarita Madness vs. Tropical Rum Punch đ„ Vote here for your favorite!”
- Hashtags: #BestRestaurantNYC #VoteLocalEats #MargaritaBattle
Step 5: Add Keyword-Rich Calls to Action
Donât end your videos with ambiguity. Send viewers directly to your online ordering page or restaurant website. Example narration: âOrder todayâs winner on our menu link below, limited-time offer!â A strategic CTA leads actions directly back to your business.
Underrated Benefits Youâre Probably Ignoring
Beyond SEO rankings, the âThis or Thatâ strategy generates additional benefits that often go overlooked. These hidden perks are what differentiate the restaurants that ride the video wave from competitors still stuck in 2019 marketing strategies.
Strengthening Google Business Profile
Many restaurant owners underestimate GBPâs impact. Short-form videos performing well on social media can be embedded directly into your Google Business listing. The results? Higher clicks from local search traffic and improved credibility.
Creating Shareable Content
Highly interactive videos drive shares from loyal customers to their networks. Many users repost voting links for co-workers, friends, or family, expanding your reach organically without costly ad spend.
Amplifying Repeat Customer Engagement
When regulars vote and see their choice promoted to win, theyâre more likely to visit again, and bring friends. This creates a feedback loop where each video campaign builds stronger loyalty than the last effort.
Common Mistakes and How To Avoid Them
Despite the apparent simplicity of âThis or That,â several pitfalls can tank engagement and harm SEO outcomes. Hereâs what you need to watch out for:
- Too Many Choices: Keep the contest between two items only. Studies show engagement drops when customers are overwhelmed with decisions.
- Poor Production Quality: Blurry visuals, shaky footage, and unreliable audio hurt credibility. Invest in basic tools like lighting rigs and stabilizing stands.
- Ignoring Mobile Formatting: More than 60% of searches occur on mobile devices. Always format your videos vertically to align with how users watch content.
- No Clear CTA: Videos without lead funnels waste momentum. Always direct viewers with action-oriented links to reserve or order now.
- Failure to Respond to Comments: Social algorithms prioritize engagement. If users comment on your challenge clips, replying strengthens visibility.
Integrating âThis or Thatâ into Your Current Strategy
If youâre thinking of experimenting with this tactic, hereâs exactly how you can transition:
Step 1: Build a Content Calendar
Plan weekly challenges ahead by identifying dishes, filming prep, and scheduling posts. Synchronize launch dates with seasonal promotions for added relevance.
Step 2: Cross-Post Strategically
Donât limit visibility to TikTok. Repost snippets to Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts for multi-platform distribution.
Step 3: Track Metrics
Monitor progress relentlessly, CTR, watch duration, voting participation, and sales correlations. Platforms like TikTok and Meta provide detailed analytics dashboards.
Step 4: Combine Tactics
Pair the âThis or Thatâ challenge with blog posts or local partnerships to extend its reach. For example, promote a neighborhood cooking competition where winning votes tie into the featured campaign item.
Ready to bring this powerhouse strategy into your marketing mix? For personalized assistance and expert tips, visit our Restaurant SEO services page. Letâs make sure your restaurant stays ahead in the game-changing world of short-form content and local search marketing.
Check out another article that you might like:
Conclusion
As the restaurant industry evolves, leveraging innovative strategies like the âThis or Thatâ video challenge is no longer optional, itâs essential. Short-form, comparative video content not only captivates audiences but also satisfies modern SEO algorithms, making it the fastest-growing organic growth channel for local restaurants. In a world where 76% of local searches with purchase intent lead to visits within 24 hours, engaging diners with authentic and interactive campaigns is key to staying ahead. From boosting click-through rates by 45% to increasing average watch times and revenue through compelling calls to action, this dynamic tactic transforms casual viewers into loyal customers.
Donât let your restaurant fall behind in the competitive SEO race of 2026. Start creating memorable video challenges that excite your audience and optimize your local search visibility. Looking for additional strategies to elevate your restaurant’s presence? Explore MELA-approved insights and marketing opportunities that cater to dinersâ growing preference for wellness-focused dining and authentic, appealing content. With MELA AIâs support, your restaurant can dominate the ever-changing digital landscape while championing quality, health-conscious meals that keep customers coming back for more. Join the movement today!
Frequently Asked Questions About “This or That” Video Challenges for Restaurant SEO
How do “This or That” video challenges improve local search rankings?
âThis or Thatâ video challenges are a game-changer for restaurant SEO because they align perfectly with what Google and other search engines now prioritize in local search rankings: engagement, authenticity, and user intent. By creating short-form videos where two menu items compete and encouraging users to vote, these challenges increase click-through rates (CTR), average watch times, and audience interactions, all of which signal quality content to search algorithms. For example, embedding such videos on Google Business Profiles (GBP) boosts engagement metrics, raising your visibility in local search results. Additionally, the built-in calls to action like âOrder the winner today!â create immediate purchase intent, converting online viewers into on-site diners. Studies demonstrate that restaurants using video in their marketing strategy see 45% higher CTR compared to static images, directly improving their local SEO performance. This means more eyes on your restaurant, both in search rankings and real life, making it a must-use tactic for 2026.
Why are short-form videos more effective than static images in local SEO?
Short-form videos excel because they engage users at a much deeper level than static images ever could. Platforms like TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts prioritize authentic, interactive content, which sharply aligns with Googleâs E-E-A-T principles (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness). Videos grab attention immediately and sustain it longer; this helps boost key SEO metrics like average watch time, an important factor for search engines. The interactive and dynamic nature of videos increases emotional connection and encourages viewers to act, whether by voting, sharing, or booking a table. For example, “This or That” challenges captivate audiences by letting them participate, so theyâre more likely to recall and engage with your restaurant. By embedding these videos on search-optimized profiles like GBP, restaurants not only attract clicks but also signal relevance and quality, giving them an edge in competitive local searches.
How can âThis or Thatâ video content drive foot traffic to your restaurant?
âThese or Thatâ videos are designed to convert online engagement into real-world action. The secret lies in their built-in interactivity: by asking viewers to vote for their favorite dish or drink, you create a sense of involvement and urgency. Once a winner emerges, you can promote it as a special offer, such as âGet 20% off todayâs winning dish!â This tactic not only excites existing customers but also catches the attention of nearby diners searching for places to eat. Furthermore, about 76% of local searches with purchase intent result in visits within 24 hours. By pairing âThis or Thatâ challenges with strategic calls to action, like links to online ordering pages or reservation systems, restaurants convert fleeting attention into reserved tables or takeaway orders. This type of marketing creates a direct bridge between social media buzz and physical foot traffic.
Which platforms are best for running “This or That” video campaigns?
Platforms like TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts are ideal for running âThis or Thatâ video campaigns, as they specialize in short-form, engaging content. TikTok leads the way with its algorithm designed to amplify content based on how engaging it is, making this platform a hotspot for reaching new audiences. Instagram Reels is another excellent option, particularly for restaurants already leveraging visual content on Instagram. Reels offers built-in tools like polls and interactive stickers, which are great for “This or That” challenges. YouTube Shorts, meanwhile, provides exposure to Google-owned ecosystems, connecting your videos to broader search initiatives. The real power lies in expanding visibility by cross-posting content. By publishing your challenge on multiple platforms, you maximize audience reach and engagement, all while reinforcing your SEO efforts through consistent branding across channels.
What types of dishes or drinks should restaurants feature in a “This or That” challenge?
The key to success in “This or That” challenges is choosing menu items that either contrast in style or highlight your restaurantâs unique offerings. For instance, pair a classic dish like âWood-fired Pizzaâ against an adventurous option like âTruffle Mushroom Pasta.â Similarly, seasonal specials can drive timely engagement, as can items catering to different dietary preferences, such as âSpicy Vegan Burgerâ vs. âClassic Beef Sliders.â Use popular, crowd-pleasing dishes to spark curiosity or introduce new menu items you want people to try. Ensure your selections reflect your brand: a seafood joint might pit âGrilled Lobsterâ against âShrimp Tacos,â while a cocktail bar could showcase âMargarita Madnessâ vs. âRum Punch Royale.â Making the challenge relatable and exciting is vital for grabbing attention while promoting items diners associate with your restaurant identity.
How can restaurants integrate âThis or Thatâ challenges into their current SEO strategy?
To integrate âThis or Thatâ challenges into your SEO strategy, begin by optimizing content for search intent and local relevance. First, ensure the videos include keyword-rich captions and tags, for example, âVote now for the best dessert in Austin! #LocalEats #BestAustinRestaurant.â Post the challenges on platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube, and embed them directly into your Google Business Profile (GBP). Additionally, create a content calendar that aligns the challenges with seasonal promotions or events, such as holiday-themed dishes. To maximize success, tie each video to a clear call to action. For example, direct viewers to a web page where they can reserve tables, order the winning dish, or subscribe to future challenges. Tracking metrics like CTR, watch time, and conversions will help refine your campaigns while keeping your SEO efforts measurable and impactful.
Are âThis or Thatâ challenges suitable for all types of restaurants?
Yes, âThis or Thatâ challenges can benefit a wide variety of restaurant types, from fast-casual eateries to fine-dining establishments. The tacticâs flexibility allows it to adapt to any brand identity or customer base. Casual restaurants can use fun, approachable themes like âTaco Tuesday Showdown: Carnitas vs. Veggie,â whereas high-end venues might showcase premium dishes like âLobster Tail vs. Filet Mignon.â Even niche establishments, such as vegan cafes or dessert parlors, can use this strategy to highlight their unique offerings. Since the goal is engagement and participation, effectively tailoring the content to your target audienceâs preferences and dining habits ensures widespread appeal.
How can MELA AI help restaurants implement video strategies like âThis or Thatâ?
MELA AI is the perfect platform for restaurants in Malta and Gozo to elevate their marketing with cutting-edge strategies like âThis or Thatâ video challenges. The MELA AI team offers specialized restaurant SEO services that help you optimize short-form video content for local search visibility. With MELAâs expertise, restaurants can craft challenges tailored to health-conscious diners or trend-focused foodies. By integrating video content into your MELA AI restaurant profile, complete with keyword optimization and targeted promotions, you gain better visibility among locals actively searching for dining options. Moreover, MELA helps track measurable results, providing insights into how such campaigns drive more foot traffic and online orders.
Does consistency matter in running “This or That” campaigns?
Absolutely. Success lies in consistency, as repeated engagement builds stronger connections with your audience. Running challenges weekly or bi-weekly keeps your restaurant top of mind for diners while establishing ongoing anticipation for your content. Consistent posting also strengthens your SEO, as regular content updates signal activity to search engines, improving your ranking score. To maintain momentum, rotate themes, such as âAppetizer Editionâ one week and âCocktail Showdownâ another, tailoring each challenge to relevant dine-in trends or promotions. The more frequent and creative you are, the more likely customers will return to participate, and dine, in the future.
Is social proof generated from these video challenges important for SEO?
Yes, social proof generated from “This or That” challenges plays a critical role in boosting local SEO. Comments, likes, shares, and votes on video challenges signal to both search engines and potential customers that your restaurant is buzzing with activity. This engagement shows authenticity, which aligns with Google’s E-E-A-T standards. Positive interactions from real customers influence algorithms to rank your content higher but also encourage new diners to view your restaurant as trustworthy. MELA AI users, for example, can measure the social proof impact of campaigns through detailed analytics, ensuring your efforts are driving both deeper trust and better rankings.
About the Author
Violetta Bonenkamp, also known as MeanCEO, is an experienced startup founder with an impressive educational background including an MBA and four other higher education degrees. She has over 20 years of work experience across multiple countries, including 5 years as a solopreneur and serial entrepreneur. Throughout her startup experience she has applied for multiple startup grants at the EU level, in the Netherlands and Malta, and her startups received quite a few of those. Sheâs been living, studying and working in many countries around the globe and her extensive multicultural experience has influenced her immensely.
Violetta is a true multiple specialist who has built expertise in Linguistics, Education, Business Management, Blockchain, Entrepreneurship, Intellectual Property, Game Design, AI, SEO, Digital Marketing, cyber security and zero code automations. Her extensive educational journey includes a Master of Arts in Linguistics and Education, an Advanced Master in Linguistics from Belgium (2006-2007), an MBA from Blekinge Institute of Technology in Sweden (2006-2008), and an Erasmus Mundus joint program European Master of Higher Education from universities in Norway, Finland, and Portugal (2009).
She is the founder of Fe/male Switch, a startup game that encourages women to enter STEM fields, and also leads CADChain, and multiple other projects like the Directory of 1,000 Startup Cities with a proprietary MeanCEO Index that ranks cities for female entrepreneurs. Violetta created the “gamepreneurship” methodology, which forms the scientific basis of her startup game. She also builds a lot of SEO tools for startups. Her achievements include being named one of the top 100 women in Europe by EU Startups in 2022 and being nominated for Impact Person of the year at the Dutch Blockchain Week. She is an author with Sifted and a speaker at different Universities. Recently she published a book on Startup Idea Validation the right way: from zero to first customers and beyond, launched a Directory of 1,500+ websites for startups to list themselves in order to gain traction and build backlinks and is building MELA AI to help local restaurants in Malta get more visibility online.
For the past several years Violetta has been living between the Netherlands and Malta, while also regularly traveling to different destinations around the globe, usually due to her entrepreneurial activities. This has led her to start writing about different locations and amenities from the POV of an entrepreneur. Hereâs her recent article about the best hotels in Italy to work from.
