Why Coffee Feels Different as You Age – Malta’s Caffeine Truth

November 24, 2025 at 06:00 AM
The Independent

As we age, our relationship with coffee often changes due to factors like slower metabolism, hormonal shifts, and genetics, leading to increased sensitivity to caffeine. This can result in symptoms such as anxiety, palpitations, and sleep disturbances, especially for those over 40. In Malta, where coffee is a cherished cultural ritual, this shift doesn’t mean giving up the experience entirely. Adjustments like switching to decaf, timing caffeine intake earlier in the day, and pairing coffee with balanced meals can help manage its effects. Malta’s café scene also offers a growing range of alternatives, from chicory coffee to herbal teas and superfood lattes, catering to health-conscious consumers. Embracing these changes can allow coffee lovers to continue enjoying their rituals while prioritizing their well-being.

Why You Might Be Struggling with Coffee – The Truth About Caffeine and Ageing

Ah, coffee. It’s more than just a morning ritual; it’s a cultural staple that fuels our fast-paced lives. Here in Malta, coffee is not just a drink—it’s a social experience. Whether it’s a quick espresso at a local café in Valletta or a leisurely cappuccino overlooking the sea in Sliema, coffee is an integral part of our dining scene and daily routine. But what happens when your once-beloved brew starts to disagree with you? If you’ve ever felt jittery, anxious, or unable to stomach your usual cup, you’re not alone—and age might be playing a bigger role than you think.

For many, coffee has always been a reliable pick-me-up, a comforting habit that adds joy to daily life. But as we grow older, some of us find that coffee’s effects can shift dramatically. What once gave us energy can now leave us feeling unsettled, with an uneasy stomach or racing thoughts. This isn’t just a personal quirk—it’s a physiological change that many people experience as they age.

The Science Behind Caffeine Sensitivity

Caffeine is absorbed quickly, usually within an hour of consumption, and it reaches peak levels in the bloodstream 30 to 60 minutes after drinking. But its half-life—the time it takes for caffeine levels in your body to drop by half—varies widely. For healthy adults, it’s typically three to seven hours, but this can stretch to over nine hours depending on factors like age, genetics, medications, and hormonal changes. Nutritionist Emily English explains how these variations mean “the same coffee can feel fine for one person and too stimulating for another.”

As we age, our metabolism naturally slows, and the enzymes in our liver responsible for breaking down caffeine (primarily CYP1A2) become less efficient. This results in caffeine lingering in the body longer, amplifying its effects. “Many people do become more sensitive to caffeine as they get older,” says Nichola Ludlam-Raine, a registered dietitian and spokesperson for the British Dietetic Association (BDA). This shift can start as early as your forties, especially during periods of hormonal change such as perimenopause. Oestrogen, for example, can slow caffeine metabolism, causing it to remain in the system longer and increasing the likelihood of side effects like anxiety, palpitations, or sleep disturbances.

Why Coffee Impacts Us Differently

It’s not just ageing that influences our relationship with caffeine. Genetics play a significant role, too. Research from the University of Bath highlights a mutation in the CYP1A2 gene that determines whether someone metabolizes caffeine quickly or slowly. This explains why some people can enjoy multiple cups a day without issue, while others feel jittery after just one. Factors like sleep quality, diet, smoking, and lifestyle also affect how we process caffeine, making each person’s tolerance highly individual.

Interestingly, studies show that older coffee drinkers—those between 65 and 70—take 33% longer to metabolize caffeine than their younger counterparts. While this doesn’t mean you need to give up your morning coffee, it does suggest that moderation becomes more important as we age.

How to Manage Increased Caffeine Sensitivity

If you’re finding it harder to handle coffee, don’t worry—there are steps you can take to reduce its impact without giving it up entirely. Switching to decaf or “half-caf” coffee (a mix of regular and decaf) can help ease the transition. In Malta, many cafés now offer specialty coffee blends with reduced caffeine or alternatives like chicory coffee, which has a similar flavor profile without the stimulating effects.

Timing is key, too. Avoiding caffeine later in the day, particularly after 2pm, can prevent it from interfering with your sleep. Pairing your morning coffee with a protein- and fiber-rich breakfast—think whole-grain toast topped with avocado or a bowl of oats with local honey—can help stabilize blood sugar levels and minimize the jittery effects of caffeine.

Hydration is another crucial factor. Drinking a glass of water before your coffee can keep you hydrated and support digestion, especially if you’re enjoying a rich brew like a Maltese-style lungo. And while it might sound counterintuitive, cutting back gradually on your caffeine intake can actually help your body adjust and reduce symptoms over time.

Coffee Culture in Malta: A Healthier Approach

Malta’s vibrant café scene offers plenty of opportunities to explore alternatives. Many coffee shops now cater to health-conscious customers with decaf options, herbal teas, and even caffeine-free superfood lattes made with ingredients like turmeric or matcha. If you’re sensitive to caffeine, why not try a chicory coffee or a refreshing barley-based drink, both of which are becoming more popular in health-focused establishments across the island? Pair them with a light breakfast or snack featuring local produce, such as fresh fruit, nuts, or whole-grain baked goods, to keep your energy levels steady throughout the day.

For those who still crave the ritual of coffee without its side effects, Malta’s restaurants and cafés offer an array of creative alternatives. From almond milk lattes to energizing herbal infusions, there’s something for everyone seeking a healthier lifestyle without compromising on flavor or experience.

Embracing Change in Your Coffee Habit

If your body is telling you it’s time to rethink your coffee routine, there’s no need to despair. While increased caffeine sensitivity isn’t reversible—it’s largely influenced by genetics, age, and hormones—you can adapt your habits to better suit your changing needs. Whether it’s swapping your third cup for decaf, spacing out your caffeine intake, or exploring Malta’s growing selection of coffee alternatives, there are plenty of ways to enjoy the ritual without the jitters.

So, the next time you find yourself sitting at a quaint café in Mdina or enjoying a seaside brunch in St. Julian’s, consider embracing a new approach to your coffee habit. After all, a healthier lifestyle doesn’t mean giving up what you love—it’s about finding balance and making choices that help you feel your best.